Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

Ahead of New York loss, Bernie Sanders blasts closed primary as “wrong”

Bernie Sanders at Penn State on Tuesday.
Bernie Sanders at Penn State on Tuesday.
Bernie Sanders at Penn State on Tuesday.
(Photo by Jeff Swensen/Getty Images)

Bernie Sanders ripped into New York’s primary voting system on Tuesday as a betrayal of democratic government that is preventing millions of people from having a say in choosing the country’s next president.

Speaking in New York City, Sanders criticized the state for holding a “closed primary” in which voters must be registered with a party in order to cast a ballot.

“Today, 3 million people in the state of New York who are independents have lost their right to vote in the Democratic or Republican primary,” Sanders said, according to the New York Daily News. “That’s wrong.”

Of course, the political parties don’t have a legal obligation to ensure that anyone can participate in choosing their presidential nominees. But their primary elections are bankrolled at least in part by the government, and that’s one reason they should be open to anyone who wants to participate, Sanders said.

“You’re paying for this election,” he told one supporter. “It’s administered by the state. You have a right to vote. And that’s a very unfortunate thing, which I hope will change.”

Why Sanders is making this attack now

Clinton in Chappaqua, New York, on Tuesday

New York is far from the only state to hold a closed primary, and requiring party registration to participate in the primary is a fairly standard practice.

There’s also a way in which this attack may come off as self-serving for Sanders. As Vox’s Ezra Klein points out, Sanders didn’t raise this objection after winning closed caucus states like Colorado and Alaska.

Still, Sanders’s attack on closed primaries may have greater force in New York, where there have been mounting concerns about how voting in the state was handled.

More than 60,000 voters previously registered in Brooklyn mysteriously disappeared from the Democratic voter rolls, WNYC reported. Complaints about difficulty casting votes were rampant in New York today. NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio has called for an audit after widespread concerns.

And New York doesn’t just have a primary closed to independents; it also has the earliest deadline to switch party registration of any state in the country. As Sanders says, that really is making it much more difficult for voters to pick their presidential candidates.

More in Politics

The Logoff
Trump’s DOJ wants to undo January 6 convictionsTrump’s DOJ wants to undo January 6 convictions
The Logoff

How the Trump administration is still trying to rewrite January 6 history.

By Cameron Peters
Politics
Donald Trump messed with the wrong popeDonald Trump messed with the wrong pope
Politics

Trump fought with Pope Francis before. He’s finding Pope Leo XIV to be a tougher foil.

By Christian Paz
Podcasts
A cautionary tale about tax cutsA cautionary tale about tax cuts
Podcast
Podcasts

California cut property taxes in the 1970s. It didn’t go so well.

By Miles Bryan and Noel King
Podcasts
Obama’s top Iran negotiator on Trump’s screwupsObama’s top Iran negotiator on Trump’s screwups
Podcast
Podcasts

Wendy Sherman helped Obama reach a deal with Iran. Here’s what she thinks Trump is doing wrong.

By Kelli Wessinger and Noel King
Politics
The Supreme Court could legalize moonshine, and ruin everything elseThe Supreme Court could legalize moonshine, and ruin everything else
Politics

McNutt v. DOJ could allow the justices to seize tremendous power over the US economy.

By Ian Millhiser
The Logoff
The new Hormuz blockade, briefly explainedThe new Hormuz blockade, briefly explained
The Logoff

Trump tries Iran’s playbook.

By Cameron Peters