Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

And just like that, Boehner’s back?

Kevin McCarthy’s decision to step aside in the race for the speakership was an absolute bombshell. Though his announcement was surprising, McCarthy’s predicament was obvious: While he almost certainly had a majority of Republican votes for yesterday’s (now postponed) vote, he couldn’t count on garnering the required 218 votes for the actual speaker election.

The announcement exploded so loudly Thursday that John Boehner’s attempt to calm the masses has barely been heard. As Roll Call reported:

“As I have said previously, I will serve as Speaker until the House votes to elect a new Speaker,” Boehner said in a written statement early Thursday afternoon. “ We will announce the date for this election at a later date, and I’m confident we will elect a new Speaker in the coming weeks.”

I’ll admit, I hadn’t noticed earlier that Boehner’s resignation was conditional on the choice of a replacement. This is further evidence of Boehner’s strengths as a leader, as I wrote about before.

More generally, though, it’s an even better version of my own strategy for how Boehner could retain the speakership, which involved having the House vote to replace him only after the replacement candidate had secured 218 votes. I’m not saying that Boehner stole my idea and put a classy Keyser Soze spin on it, but I’m not saying he didn’t, either.

I don’t know if Boehner’s trying to remain speaker or not, but the magical part of his position right now is that regardless of anything his colleagues may think about him, he has one thing that nobody else has: John Boehner doesn’t need to be elected speaker of the House.

How this will evolve over the next couple of days is uncertain, but I will predict that if a consensus candidate does not emerge by Monday, John Boehner will still be speaker in January 2017. Given that Paul Ryan seems intent on not being speaker (arguably because he’s a smart politician with higher ambitions), this will be an interesting weekend.

Finally, I think it is interesting to note that Paul Ryan was to nominate McCarthy for the speakership. Boehner basically endorsed McCarthy for the speakership in his “resignation” speech. Ryan said early on that he didn’t want the job. In spite of protesting that he was surprised today, three’s a crowd when it comes to the House leadership. I find it very hard to believe that the whole dynamic starting with Boehner’s resignation has been as unforeseen to them as it has been to the rest of us.

In any event, it may turn out that the most powerful stunt John Boehner ever pulled was convincing his caucus he was giving up his power.

Mischiefs of Faction
Brazil’s Supreme Court pushed back against an attempt to cancel participatory councilsBrazil’s Supreme Court pushed back against an attempt to cancel participatory councils
Mischiefs of Faction

That’s good news for Brazilian democracy.

By Carla Bezerra and Lindsay Mayka
Mischiefs of Faction
Six political scientists react to the first Democratic primary debatesSix political scientists react to the first Democratic primary debates
Mischiefs of Faction

A good event for the upper tier of candidates, a bad one for Biden, and a forgettable one for the ones you’ve already forgotten.

By Richard Skinner, Seth Masket and 4 more
Mischiefs of Faction
Technology and transparency: the path to a modern Congress?Technology and transparency: the path to a modern Congress?
Mischiefs of Faction

We’re starting to see the direction of a committee dedicated to changing Capitol Hill.

By Richard Skinner
Mischiefs of Faction
Brazil’s Bolsonaro took a page from US politics by dangling the possibility of an evangelical Supreme Court JusticeBrazil’s Bolsonaro took a page from US politics by dangling the possibility of an evangelical Supreme Court Justice
Mischiefs of Faction

But US evangelicals have been more loyal to Trump than Brazil’s evangelicals have been to President Bolsonaro, so this move may not work.

By Amy Erica Smith
Mischiefs of Faction
What’s motivating the DNC’s debate rulesWhat’s motivating the DNC’s debate rules
Mischiefs of Faction

Democrats are trying to learn from 2016 and prevent the same problems in the nomination race.

By Seth Masket
Mischiefs of Faction
Why everyone runs for president these daysWhy everyone runs for president these days
Mischiefs of Faction

For the second presidential cycle in a row, there’s a record-breaking number of candidates in the nominee race.

By Rachel Bitecofer