Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

This is what happens when you ask regular people in China about Tiananmen

Liu Wei

However famous the June 4, 1989, Tiananmen massacre may be outside of China, it is barely known in the country where it occurred. This can be baffling for outsiders: how could the Chinese government enforce this vast national amnesia of a major, recent event in their country’s history, one in which the government sent troops to slaughter perhaps 2,600 peaceful protesters? How, in a country as well-educated and cosmopolitan as China, could this even be possible?

This 2005 short documentary “A Day Forgotten,” made by Chinese filmmaker Liu Wei and flagged by China File’s Susie Jakes, may be one of the most powerful and affecting attempts at an answer. The premise of the documentary is simple: Liu spends the 2005 anniversary of the Tiananmen massacre walking around asking people “do you know what day it is today” and films their response.

The reactions’ on peoples’ faces as they process his question, and the ways that they attempt to answer, is a powerful depiction of what it means to have your government forcefully suppress the memory of a painful national event. It’s clear that the censorship goes way beyond shutting down news coverage and jailing dissidents — it’s succeeded in getting regular people to internalize self-censorship. Some appear earnestly unaware, some find a way to signal their understanding without saying it outright. Others simply jog away, so sensitive is Tiananmen’s memory that even asking the date on June 4 can scare people into flight.

When this was filmed, the massacre had been 16 years earlier — a little bit more time than has passed between the September 11, 2001, attacks and now. About as many people died in New York on September 11 as died in Beijing on June 4. Imagine if, on September 12, 2001, the US government had declared the previous day’s attacks a non-event, ordered a complete media blackout, and enforced a campaign of censorship and intimidation so severe that even today people would run away if someone with a handheld camera asked them on September 11, 2014, what the date was.

See More:

More in archives

archives
Ethics and Guidelines at Vox.comEthics and Guidelines at Vox.com
archives
By Vox Staff
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court will decide if the government can ban transgender health careThe Supreme Court will decide if the government can ban transgender health care
Supreme Court

Given the Court’s Republican supermajority, this case is unlikely to end well for trans people.

By Ian Millhiser
archives
On the MoneyOn the Money
archives

Learn about saving, spending, investing, and more in a monthly personal finance advice column written by Nicole Dieker.

By Vox Staff
archives
Total solar eclipse passes over USTotal solar eclipse passes over US
archives
By Vox Staff
archives
The 2024 Iowa caucusesThe 2024 Iowa caucuses
archives

The latest news, analysis, and explainers coming out of the GOP Iowa caucuses.

By Vox Staff
archives
The Big SqueezeThe Big Squeeze
archives

The economy’s stacked against us.

By Vox Staff