Home Depot Breach Bigger Than Target’s at 56 Million Cards

Home Depot said Thursday that some 56 million payment cards were likely compromised in a cyber attack at its stores, suggesting the attack at the home improvement chain was larger than last year’s unprecedented breach at Target.

Home Depot, in providing the first clues to how much the breach would cost, said that so far it has estimated costs of $62 million. But it indicated that costs could reach much higher.

It will take months to determine the full scope of the fraud, which affected Home Depot stores in both the United States and Canada and ran from April to September.

Retailer Target incurred costs of $148 million in its second fiscal quarter related to its breach. Target hackers stole at least 40 million payment card numbers and 70 million other pieces of customer data.

In its most complete account of what had happened since it first disclosed the breach on Sept. 8, Home Depot said that criminals used unique, custom-built software that had not been seen in previous attacks and was designed to evade detection.

The company said that the hackers’ method of entry has been closed off, the malware eliminated from its network, and that it had rolled out “enhanced encryption of payment data” to all U.S. stores.

“We apologize to our customers for the inconvenience and anxiety this has caused and want to reassure them that they will not be liable for fraudulent charges,” Chief Executive Frank Blake said in a statement.

Of the estimated cost so far of $62 million, which covers such items as credit monitoring, increased call center staffing, and legal and professional services, Home Depot said it believes that $27 million of the amount will be paid for by insurers.

But the company said it has not yet estimated the impact of “probable losses” related to the possible need to reimburse banks for fraud and card replacement, as well as covering costs of lawsuits and government investigations.

“Those costs may have a material adverse effect on The Home Depot’s financial results in the fourth quarter and/or future periods,” the company said in its statement.

Wesley McGrew, an expert on retail breaches and an assistant research professor at the department of computer science at Mississippi State University, said that Home Depot is going to be expected to bear the costs related to fraud and payment card replacement.

Banks typically seek to get retailers to cover those costs if there are any indications of shortcomings in their security.

Criminals have frequently used software that evades detection, but retailers are expected to closely monitor their networks using tools that are designed to uncover signs of a crime in progress, McGrew said.

“It’s hard to feel sorry for them when there are things they could have done to improve the security of these transactions,” McGrew said.

Hitesh Sheth, chief executive of Vectra Networks, a cyber security firm in San Jose, Calif., said Home Depot’s breach exposes a weakness, noting that the company said hackers used unique, custom-built malware.

That “essentially means the technology they are using is only designed to detect malware that has already been used in a previous attack, and that is symptomatic of the retail industry,” Sheth said.

“Retailers need to upgrade to technology that is available and detects behavior of malware that is new because these attacks are not going to stop anytime soon.”

For its fiscal year ending in February, Home Depot revised its earnings estimate to $4.54 per share from $4.52. In addition to the cost related to the breach, it said the estimate includes a pre-tax gain of about $100 million on the sale of 3.6 million common shares of HD Supply stock.

The company left its outlook for sales growth for the year at 4.8 percent.

(Reporting by Jim Finkle in Boston and Nandita Bose in Chicago; Additional reporting by Shailaja Sharma in Bangalore; Editing by Leslie Adler and Jilian Mincer)

This article originally appeared on Recode.net.