Recommending books can be a tricky endeavor. If someone comes away from Wuthering Heights flush with enjoyment and looking for more, do you suggest a gothic romance? A Brontë biography? Or do you hand her a walking guide to the moors? (Honestly, that walking guide would probably be amazing, but we understand your concern.)
Many readers are voracious, and it suits them. But if you've ever liked one element of a book only to keep running up against recommendations that don't seem to spark quite the same interest, the idea of selecting something to read based on its individual components takes on a certain charm. This sort of detective work carries a particular urgency during the holidays; you know your friend liked H Is for Hawk, but the particular motive eludes you, and you have to choose between a literary memoir and an overview of medieval hunts posthaste. (Those are good choices; you're an awesome friend.)
We've collected several major book releases from this year and used them as a starting point to recommend titles that reflect some of their best elements. It's almost impossible to map all the overlapping tastes that converge in a single book, but it's the kind of game where everybody comes out a winner.












































