Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump said they want to debate each other. Yes, really.

Libby Nelson
Libby Nelson was Vox’s editorial director, politics and policy, leading coverage of how government action and inaction shape American life. Libby has more than a decade of policy journalism experience, including at Inside Higher Ed and Politico. She joined Vox in 2014.

Hillary Clinton says she has no interest in debating Bernie Sanders before California’s Democratic Primary. But if she won’t, Donald Trump will.

On ABC’s Jimmy Kimmel Live! on Wednesday night, Kimmel asked Trump if he’d be willing to debate Sanders instead, with the proceeds going to charity. Trump said he would. And Sanders tweeted a few minutes later that he’s in.

After Clinton initially turned down an invitation to debate Sanders on Fox News, the network considered hosting a Sanders-Trump debate in February, the New York Times’ Nick Corasaniti reported in March. But Trump pulled out at the last minute, citing “scheduling conflicts.”

If the debate actually happens this time around — and if it’s going to, Sanders and Trump need to find a network to host it — it would be unprecedented. The Democratic National Committee and the Republican National Committee both frown on networks inviting candidates to debates that the committees didn’t approve.

But the committees mostly enforce those rules by threatening networks’ access to and candidates’ participation in future primary debates. Since Trump has the nomination locked down and the California primary is almost the last of the 2016 cycle, if Sanders and Trump want to debate and a network will host it, their parties might not be able to stop them.

Trump, being Trump, is now suggesting that it might just all have been a joke:

But embracing the idea and backtracking on it are both emblematic of Trump’s campaign.

Trump knows how to make great television

Donald Trump was a successful television personality because he understands what makes great television. (Even if that meant embracing disturbing ideas, like The Apprentice: Race War.)

And a Sanders-Trump debate certainly could be wildly entertaining: two unconventional, older New Yorkers, neither of whom can pronounce “huge” correctly, defending their very different beliefs.

It’s less clear why Sanders — who would need to win California in a historic landslide to capture the nomination — would go along with this. Sanders insists he could still win, but if he really believed he was going to, there’s an easy response to Trump’s challenge: that he looks forward to debating Trump on September 26, when the first general election debate is scheduled.

There could, imaginably, be some value in watching Sanders and Trump, or any two candidates from opposing parties, face off. Sanders can attack Trump on issues Republicans have hesitated to engage with for fear of alienating their base: his racist remarks and proposed policies, his business record, his wealth. Equally, Democratic voters would get a chance to see how Sanders responds to much more savage attacks on his proposed tax increases and his identification as a democratic socialist.

In general, debates between candidates of opposing parties while the primary process is still going on might not be a terrible idea. Voters might want to know where their prospective candidates are vulnerable to general election attacks from the other party, or how they might moderate their positions if they’re criticized.

But that information is only useful if voters still have options to choose from. And when both parties essentially have their nominees, it’s awfully late to schedule an inter-party debate. So we’re left with this: It could be awfully entertaining. Two comedians, James Adomian and Anthony Atamanuik, have been embracing the idea with a very funny “Trump versus Bernie” debate tour for months.


The map we see every presidential election is pretty much useless

Politics
A Trump judge’s new decision would undo more than 50 years of voting rights lawA Trump judge’s new decision would undo more than 50 years of voting rights law
Politics

Trump Judge Lee Rudofsky’s decision could completely neutralize the Voting Rights Act when the GOP controls the White House.

By Ian Millhiser
Politics
President Trump is considering pardoning himself. I asked 15 experts if that’s legal.President Trump is considering pardoning himself. I asked 15 experts if that’s legal.
Politics

Is a self-pardon constitutional? The answer is strangely murky.

By Sean Illing
Politics
Sexual assault allegations against Donald Trump: more women come forwardSexual assault allegations against Donald Trump: more women come forward
Explainers
Trump’s long history of racism, from the 1970s to 2020Trump’s long history of racism, from the 1970s to 2020
Explainers

Trump has repeatedly claimed he’s “the least racist person.” His history suggests otherwise.

By German Lopez
Politics
New Hampshire shouldn’t be the first primaryNew Hampshire shouldn’t be the first primary
Politics

Take it from me, a New Hampshirite: The current system is horrendously unfair.

By Dylan Matthews
Politics
New Hampshire primary 2016: updates and resultsNew Hampshire primary 2016: updates and results
Politics

The New Hampshire primary kicks off on Tuesday, February 9. Polls will close for nearly all of the state at 7 pm Eastern, while some additional polling places will close at 8 pm Eastern.

By Vox Staff