Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

Here’s the software that could have saved Melania Trump from her plagiarism debacle

Donald Trump’s campaign co-chair mentioned TurnItIn.com in an interview today.

Melania Trump at the Republican National Convention: Day One
Melania Trump at the Republican National Convention: Day One
Chip Somodevilla / Getty Images

Last night at the Republican National Convention, Melania Trump, wife of presumptive nominee Donald Trump, gave a speech that bore an uncanny resemblance, as critics almost immediately pointed out, to a speech given by Michelle Obama at the Democratic National Convention in 2008, when her husband was the presumptive nominee.

Today on MSNBC, the Trump campaign’s national co-chair, Sam Clovis, mentioned a bit of software that would have prevented the whole debacle:

“I’ll tell ya, I’m a college professor, and I use TurnItIn.com all the time … That’s a software that allows you to check out different things.”

Or, as Recode’s own Ina Fried put it:

Clovis, who lost an Iowa senate race last year, was at one point the chairman of the economics and business administration department at Morningside College, though he is not currently listed on that school’s site.

TurnItIn is a subscription service currently in use, the company says, at 12,000 educational institutions around the globe. Founded by Berkeley neuroscientists in the late 1990s, the service compares text against web content, previous submissions, and scholarly journals and magazines to generate an “originality report.” The report highlights text that matches another source.

As it happens, TurnItIn ran one of its reports on Mrs. Trump’s speech and found several types of plagiarism.

“Clone” Plagiarism

In this type of plagiarism, the exact same words appear in both the original and the copy. TurnItIn found 23 identical words when comparing the two speeches. Despite the Trump campaign’s claim that Mrs. Trump simply used “common words and values,” TurnItIn calculates the likelihood of this coincidence as a “one in one trillion chance.”

“Find-Replace” Plagiarism

Another type of appropriation studied by the company concerns text that “retains the content or meaning” of someone else’s work — for instance, if a paragraph only changes a few words. The company was able to provide an image of the close match between a section of the two speeches:

Side-by-side color-coded notations of similarities between Michelle Obama’s 2008 speech and Melania Trump’s 2016 speech.
TurnItIn.com

In the end, said company spokesperson Chris Harrick, “This happens infrequently, because [political] teams are made up of professionals who should know better, as opposed to kids who are under a time crunch and a tremendous amount of pressure.”

But the company’s statement urges an additional takeaway from this debacle. “As a teachable moment, the question of whether Melania Trump’s speech exhibits plagiarism or not is not as helpful as looking at this controversy as an object lesson on how to avoid plagiarism.”

Sure, we’ll go with that.

Just for giggles, we ran the full text of Mrs. Trump’s speech through another site, Grammarly.com, which found “significant plagiarism.” But it costs $30/month to get a more detailed report that would explain exactly what that means and where the similarities are drawn from. Maybe the Trump campaign was short on cash.

Meanwhile, the free sites were useless, because they apparently compare against existing websites and, of course, the full text of Mrs. Trump’s speech is all over the web.

This article originally appeared on Recode.net.

See More:

More in Technology

Technology
The case for AI realismThe case for AI realism
Technology

AI isn’t going to be the end of the world — no matter what this documentary sometimes argues.

By Shayna Korol
Politics
OpenAI’s oddly socialist, wildly hypocritical new economic agendaOpenAI’s oddly socialist, wildly hypocritical new economic agenda
Politics

The AI company released a set of highly progressive policy ideas. There’s just one small problem.

By Eric Levitz
Future Perfect
Human bodies aren’t ready to travel to Mars. Space medicine can help.Human bodies aren’t ready to travel to Mars. Space medicine can help.
Future Perfect

Protecting astronauts in space — and maybe even Mars — will help transform health on Earth.

By Shayna Korol
Podcasts
The importance of space toilets, explainedThe importance of space toilets, explained
Podcast
Podcasts

Houston, we have a plumbing problem.

By Peter Balonon-Rosen and Sean Rameswaram
Technology
What happened when they installed ChatGPT on a nuclear supercomputerWhat happened when they installed ChatGPT on a nuclear supercomputer
Technology

How they’re using AI at the lab that created the atom bomb.

By Joshua Keating
Future Perfect
Humanity’s return to the moon is a deeply religious missionHumanity’s return to the moon is a deeply religious mission
Future Perfect

Space barons like Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk don’t seem religious. But their quest to colonize outer space is.

By Sigal Samuel