This article originally appeared on Recode.net.
“We’re not ready” for foreign election interference in 2020, says Rep. Adam Schiff


Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA), the chair of the House Intelligence Committee, in March 2017. Win McNamee/Getty ImagesIn May, Facebook refused to remove a deceptively edited viral video that made Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi look drunk — a decision that does not bode well for how Silicon Valley will handle disinformation and election interference in 2020, Rep. Adam Schiff says.
And for that matter, he said on the latest episode of Recode Decode with Kara Swisher, Congress and the voting public aren’t prepared to deal with those things either.
Read Article >Facebook is banning hundreds more accounts run by Russian trolls


Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg David Ramos / GettyFacebook is still finding — and banning — accounts linked to the Internet Research Agency, the Russian troll army with ties to the Kremlin that tried to sway public opinion on Facebook during the 2016 U.S. presidential election.
Facebook announced on Tuesday that has removed more than 270 Facebook and Instagram accounts controlled by the IRA. Unlike the other IRA accounts Facebook was aware of — the one’s targeting U.S. voters that were removed last fall — these accounts were “targeting people living in Russia,” Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg said in a post.
Read Article >Reddit says Russian propaganda was shared by ‘thousands’ ahead of the 2016 election

Steffen Kugler/BPA via Getty ImagesIt’s widely known that Facebook, Twitter and YouTube were used by Russian sources during the 2016 U.S. presidential election to try and sway public opinion.
Now we know for certain that Reddit was also part of Russia’s disinformation strategy.
Read Article >Facebook and Twitter worked just as advertised for Russia’s troll army

Friedemann Vogel - Pool/Getty ImagesWe’ve known for more than a year that Russian actors used social media to try and influence the 2016 presidential election.
Now we know more about those campaigns, thanks to a lengthy indictment by special counsel Robert Mueller which details the Russian effort.
Read Article >President Trump is using tweets from a Facebook executive to argue Russia didn’t influence the election

Tasos Katopodis / GettyPresident Donald Trump found an unlikely ally in his mission to convince the internet that Russia’s attempts to interfere in the 2016 U.S. election didn’t actually help get him elected: Facebook advertising executive Rob Goldman.
Goldman, Facebook’s VP of ad products, sent a series of tweets late Friday that said, among other things, that “swaying the election was *NOT* the main goal” of the thousands of dollars of Facebook ads bought by Russian actors during and after the 2016 election.
Read Article >
Tony Romm and Kurt Wagner
Here’s how to check if you interacted with Russian propaganda on Facebook during the 2016 election

Photo by Morris MacMatzen/Getty ImagesFacebook has rolled out its new hub to help some users figure out if they interacted with Russian propaganda during the 2016 U.S. presidential election.
The social giant’s tool — available here, through its Help Center — specifically allows users to see if they followed or “Liked” any pages and accounts set up by Kremlin-backed trolls on either Facebook or Instagram.
Read Article >Facebook will help some users figure out if they saw Russian propaganda during the 2016 U.S. presidential election


Colin Stretch, the general counsel of Facebook Chip Somodevilla / GettyFacebook is trying to alert some U.S. users that they fell victim to Russian propaganda during the 2016 presidential election.
In the coming weeks, the social giant plans to roll out a new tool so that users can check if they followed or “Liked” pages and accounts — on both Facebook and Instagram — that the Kremlin quietly set up over the past two years in order to sow social and political unrest, the company announced Wednesday.
Read Article >Twitter’s Jack Dorsey says he would have testified to Congress about Russia if he was invited. He was.


Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey Justin Tallis / GettyTwitter CEO Jack Dorsey said Thursday he’s “absolutely” willing to come talk to the U.S. Congress as lawmakers continue to probe Russia’s efforts to spread disinformation on social media during the 2016 U.S. presidential election.
Thing is, lawmakers previously and repeatedly called on Dorsey and other tech executives to make the trip to Capitol Hill — and they’ve apparently declined.
Read Article >Yuri Milner’s big investments in Twitter and Facebook have now been tied to the Russian government

Photo by Jemal Countess/Getty ImagesFacebook and Twitter received major investments from a firm with ties to Kremlin-owned corporations, a new trove of confidential documents revealed.
That cache of confidential documents, called the Paradise Papers, was obtained by German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung. The documents were reviewed by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists and a series of news outlets.
Read Article >
Rani Molla and Tony Romm
Here’s a longer list of news organizations that cited Russia-linked Twitter accounts

Chip Somodevilla / GettyFrom major national U.S. newspapers like the Washington Post to websites for Patch and local ABC stations, for years, reporters around the country appear to have been unknowingly including tweets from Russian trolls in their news stories, as Recode first reported this week, with help from Meltwater, a media intelligence firm.
Today, we’re sharing an expanded version of the dataset, revealing the extent to which these Twitter accounts repeatedly made the news in the U.S.
Read Article >Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said tech should cooperate with law enforcement — and help the U.S. fight Russia


Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell Mark Wilson / GettyThe Republican leader of the U.S. Senate suggested on Saturday that tech giants like Facebook, Google and Twitter could help the United States “retaliate” against Russian forces that spread disinformation on social media around the 2016 presidential election.
In doing so, though, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell also revealed that he is “skeptical” of new efforts to regulate political ads that appear on top tech platforms.
Read Article >
Tony Romm and Rani Molla
The Washington Post, Miami Herald, InfoWars and other U.S. sites spread Russian propaganda from Twitter

Drew Angerer/Getty ImagesThe tweet that opened a story in the Washington Post on Feb. 11, 2016 seemed innocuous: It was an attempt to illustrate Syrian territory occupied by clashing government and ISIS forces.
Problem is, the account behind that tweet — @WarfareWW — was one of 2,752 Twitter trolls identified this week as tied to the Russian government and suspended for spreading disinformation.
Read Article >Lawmakers are pushing Facebook to reach out to each U.S. user who saw Russian propaganda


With a Facebook event page featuring a ‘Miners For Trump’ rally created by Russian operatives displayed behind him, Sen. Chris Coons (D-DE) questions witnesses during a Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Terrorism hearing Drew Angerer/Getty ImagesU.S. lawmakers nudged Facebook on Wednesday to inform individual U.S. users — millions in total — that they saw Russian propaganda on the site during the 2016 presidential election.
The call for the company to proactively alert these users originated at a hearing before the House Intelligence Committee, where Facebook once again acknowledged that 140 million U.S. users — including on apps it owns, like Instagram — may have seen posts, pages or other content posted by Kremlin-backed trolls.
Read Article >Mark Zuckerberg didn’t testify to Congress on Russia, but says he’s ‘dead serious’ about fixing things

David Ramos / GettyMark Zuckerberg did not testify in front of Congress this week to explain how Russian actors used Facebook to try and spread disinformation during last year’s U.S. presidential election.
Facebook sent the company’s top lawyer instead.
Read Article >Congress released more Facebook and Instagram ads that Russia bought to try and influence the 2016 election


Democrats on the House Intelligence Committee released copies of 14 Facebook ads purchased by Russian trolls around the 2016 U.S. presidential election, including sponsored posts on Instagram trying to link “Killary Clinton” to the death of U.S. troops.
Some of the political ads targeted Facebook or Instagram users based on their interests in Christianity, Rush Limbaugh, the war in Afghanistan and more, according to details shared by the panel. In some cases, they garnered thousands of impressions — views, but not necessarily “Likes” or clicks — on Facebook platforms.
Read Article >Two days, three hearings and six things we still don’t know about Russia’s election meddling on social media

Chip Somodevilla/Getty ImagesAfter three congressional hearings in two days, there seems to be no doubt in the minds of U.S. lawmakers that Russia weaponized Facebook, Google and Twitter to spread disinformation and sow social unrest around the 2016 presidential election.
That doesn’t mean, however, that their investigation is finished.
Read Article >Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton spent $81 million on Facebook ads before last year’s election

Ralph Freso / GettyDonald Trump and Hillary Clinton spent big on Facebook ads last year ahead of November’s presidential election.
The two candidates and their campaigns spent a combined $81 million on ads, according to Facebook General Counsel Colin Stretch, who unveiled the number during a congressional hearing Wednesday focused on Russia’s attempt to use social platforms to interfere in the election. Facebook made about $28 billion in revenue in 2016, most of it from advertising.
Read Article >These are some of the tweets and Facebook ads Russia used to try and influence the 2016 presidential election


Representatives from Facebook, Google and Twitter were in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday to explain to Congress how Russian sources used their respective platforms to try and spread misinformation during last year’s presidential election.
The three companies took questions from U.S. senators, many of whom seemed skeptical of the power and influence that companies like Facebook have over the U.S. electorate.
Read Article >Tech is scary powerful, and other things we learned when Facebook, Google and Twitter testified to Congress about Russia

Drew Angerer / Getty ImagesSenior executives from Facebook, Google and Twitter submitted on Tuesday to the first of three hearings by the U.S. Congress as lawmakers investigate the extent to which Russia spread disinformation on their platforms during the 2016 presidential election.
And those companies got exactly what they expected: A wide-ranging grilling that called into question the industry’s size and influence, its commitment to combating the Kremlin, and even its ability to provide neutral platforms for their users’ content.
Read Article >Watch: Facebook, Google and Twitter testify to Congress about Russia and the 2016 election

Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty ImagesSenior executives from Facebook, Google and Twitter will submit on Tuesday to the first of three grueling grillings before U.S. lawmakers who are investigating Russia’s suspected interference in the 2016 presidential election.
Kicking it off is the Senate Judiciary Committee’s top crime and terrorism panel, chaired by Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham. The focus is on the extent to which Kremlin-backed agents and trolls sought to spread disinformation and extremist content on major social media platforms — and what, exactly, the U.S. Congress should do about it.
Read Article >Sen. Mark Warner isn’t sure that Facebook, Google and Twitter have fully uncovered the scope of Russia’s election meddling

Drew Angerer / GettyMore than half of the United States saw Facebook posts tied to Russian trolls during the 2016 U.S. presidential campaign, while the Kremlin had ties to thousands of accounts on Twitter. And in the eyes of Sen. Mark Warner, who’s leading a probe into the matter, the fear is that these and other tech giants have only scratched the surface in their findings.
A day before the Senate Intelligence Committee is set to grill senior Silicon Valley executives, the panel’s top Democrat, Warner, told Recode that he still isn’t sure if the tech industry has done the fullest accounting of Russia’s disinformation efforts on their platforms. To that end, he pledged to press all three companies during questioning, while urging his colleagues to support new regulations targeting online political ads.
Read Article >Tech titans support more political ad transparency — but aren’t yet embracing a new bill by the U.S. Senate

Drew Angerer / GettyHere’s what the tech industry says it wants if the U.S. Congress tries to write a new law about online political ads: Rules that are clear, apply to everyone, emphasize disclosure but not too much, and certainly don’t inhibit free speech.
And here’s what that really means: The biggest brands in Silicon Valley aren’t exactly ready to embrace a new, bipartisan bill in the U.S. Senate that would subject them to a whole host of tough regulations.
Read Article >
Kurt Wagner and Tony Romm
Facebook says 126 million people in the U.S. may have seen posts produced by Russian-government-backed agents

Mark Wilson / Getty ImagesFacebook, Google and Twitter plan to tell congressional investigators this week that the scope of Russia’s campaign to spread disinformation on their sites — and to potentially disrupt the 2016 U.S. presidential race — is much broader than the companies initially reported.
At Facebook, roughly 126 million users in the United States may have seen posts, stories or other content created by Russian government-backed trolls around Election Day, according to a source familiar with the company’s forthcoming testimony to Congress. Previously, Facebook had only shared information on ads purchased by Kremlin-tied accounts, revealing that they reached more than 10 million U.S. users.
Read Article >Sen. Dianne Feinstein is demanding more information from Facebook and Twitter about Russian users on their sites

Chip Somodevilla / GettyA powerful Democratic lawmaker from Silicon Valley’s own backyard is demanding that Facebook and Twitter turn over reams of new data about Russian disinformation spread on their platforms during the 2016 U.S. presidential election.
The new scrutiny comes from California Sen. Dianne Feinstein, and her requests — detailed in exhaustive letters to the two tech giants’ chief executives — are part of her broader probe into the Kremlin’s potential coordination with Donald Trump’s campaign.
Read Article >
Tony Romm and Kurt Wagner
Facebook is taking a stricter stance on political advertising ahead of its testimony to the U.S. Congress next week


Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg Drew Angerer / GettyFacebook is trying to make it easier to identify political ads in your News Feed.
The social giant announced on Friday it will soon require advertisers — especially political candidates — to disclose more information about their advertising efforts on the platform as the company seeks to temper concerns from the U.S. Congress about Russian meddling in the 2016 presidential election.
Read Article >