Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

Trump now says he’s “fine with” the Supreme Court’s legalization of same-sex marriage

Still, a Trump-appointed Supreme Court could possibly overturn the Court’s previous ruling.

Republican candidate Donald Trump previously called the Supreme Court’s decision to legalize same-sex marriage nationwide “shocking,” suggesting that he would work to overturn the ruling if he was elected president.

President-elect Donald Trump, however, seems to have a slightly different perspective. Asked on 60 Minutes whether he would work to overturn the ruling, Trump said that he is “fine with” how the Court ruled. He not only called his own view on marriage equality (he opposes it) “irrelevant,” but he also said that “it’s done.”

“These cases have gone to the Supreme Court,” Trump said. “They’ve been settled. And I’m fine with that.”

While Trump may believe that, it’s not necessarily true that the issue can never be revisited by the Court. After all, Trump also suggested in the 60 Minutes interview that he would like to see the ruling legalizing abortions nationwide overturned. The Court could also reconsider marriage equality — and rule differently if Trump appoints a slew of conservative justices to the bench, as he has promised to do.

“These cases have gone to the Supreme Court. They’ve been settled. And I’m fine with that.”

There is a very real possibility in the next four years that Trump will appoint as many as four justices to replace those who are either deceased or close to retirement due to their age. For one, he will surely replace the conservative and recently deceased Antonin Scalia. And he might be able to replace liberals Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer and right-leaning centrist Anthony Kennedy.

When the Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriage nationwide, it did so with three of the people on this list: Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kennedy. That means three of the five justices who backed marriage equality could be replaced by Trump and a Republican-held Senate. So if the issue somehow rises to the Supreme Court again, the new conservative justices could overturn marriage equality.

To be clear, this is extremely unlikely. Precedent is a very, very powerful force in the Supreme Court — especially when, as the polls overwhelmingly show, the majority of Americans support same-sex marriage rights. Justices are unlikely to just overturn this previous ruling on a whim.

It’s also unclear how, exactly, this issue would end back up on the Supreme Court. It previously rose to the Supreme Court because civil rights advocates sued states over their same-sex marriage bans. But there are no longer any same-sex marriage bans in effect to sue over and appeal all the way to the Supreme Court. And if a state tried to pass such a law again, lower courts would, touting the previous Supreme Court ruling, almost certainly strike the law down — leaving little need for the Court to interfere.

Still, it’s a possibility — a nightmarish one for LGBTQ people — of a Trump-appointed Supreme Court.


Watch: The march of marriage equality

More in Politics

The Logoff
Trump’s DOJ wants to undo January 6 convictionsTrump’s DOJ wants to undo January 6 convictions
The Logoff

How the Trump administration is still trying to rewrite January 6 history.

By Cameron Peters
Politics
Donald Trump messed with the wrong popeDonald Trump messed with the wrong pope
Politics

Trump fought with Pope Francis before. He’s finding Pope Leo XIV to be a tougher foil.

By Christian Paz
Podcasts
A cautionary tale about tax cutsA cautionary tale about tax cuts
Podcast
Podcasts

California cut property taxes in the 1970s. It didn’t go so well.

By Miles Bryan and Noel King
Podcasts
Obama’s top Iran negotiator on Trump’s screwupsObama’s top Iran negotiator on Trump’s screwups
Podcast
Podcasts

Wendy Sherman helped Obama reach a deal with Iran. Here’s what she thinks Trump is doing wrong.

By Kelli Wessinger and Noel King
Politics
The Supreme Court could legalize moonshine, and ruin everything elseThe Supreme Court could legalize moonshine, and ruin everything else
Politics

McNutt v. DOJ could allow the justices to seize tremendous power over the US economy.

By Ian Millhiser
The Logoff
The new Hormuz blockade, briefly explainedThe new Hormuz blockade, briefly explained
The Logoff

Trump tries Iran’s playbook.

By Cameron Peters