Skip to main content

The Big Idea

Outside contributors’ opinions and analysis of the most important issues in politics, science, and culture.

The Big Idea
The Supreme Court is an anti-democratic nightmare. Here’s how to fix it.The Supreme Court is an anti-democratic nightmare. Here’s how to fix it.
The Big Idea

Radical democracy, not judicial supremacy.

By Eric Posner and Glen Weyl
The Big Idea
How Democratic lawmakers should help unions reeling from the Janus decisionHow Democratic lawmakers should help unions reeling from the Janus decision
The Big Idea

The Supreme Court just dealt unions a harsh blow, but it doesn’t have to be a deadly one.

By Benjamin Sachs and Sharon Block
The Big Idea
The Court’s indefensible double standardThe Court’s indefensible double standard
The Big Idea

Biased comments by officials shaped the outcome of the Masterpiece Cakeshop case, but were ruled of limited importance on the travel ban.

By Ilya Somin
The Big Idea
Bias against Asian-American students is real. Affirmative action isn’t the problem.Bias against Asian-American students is real. Affirmative action isn’t the problem.
The Big Idea

We can fight stereotypes about Asian personalities while rejecting the idea that test scores are the only kind of merit.

By Stacey J. Lee and Kevin K. Kumashiro
The Big Idea
The travel ban decision echoes some of the worst Supreme Court decisions in historyThe travel ban decision echoes some of the worst Supreme Court decisions in history
The Big Idea

The logic SCOTUS used to uphold the travel ban would justify Japanese internment camps.

By Aziz Huq
The Big Idea
In MLK’s day, conservatives didn’t think he was so “civil”In MLK’s day, conservatives didn’t think he was so “civil”
The Big Idea

He also knew calls for “civility” often serve to enforce the status quo.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
How Silicon Valley workers are revolting against Trump’s immigration policyHow Silicon Valley workers are revolting against Trump’s immigration policy
The Big Idea

Tech workers have traditionally shied away from organizing. That’s changing.

By Alex Press
The Big Idea
The latest Supreme Court decision is being hailed as a victory for digital privacy. It’s not.The latest Supreme Court decision is being hailed as a victory for digital privacy. It’s not.
The Big Idea

Carpenter forces police to get a warrant before getting some cellphone data. But other Fourth Amendment cases will undermine its impact.

By Aziz Huq
The Big Idea
The Democratic Party is moving steadily leftward. So why does the left still distrust it?The Democratic Party is moving steadily leftward. So why does the left still distrust it?
The Big Idea

There’s a long tradition of left-liberal activism within the party. Today’s left should keep that tradition alive — rather than rejecting Democrats as sellouts.

By Sam Rosenfeld
The Big Idea
A plan to fight high drug prices that could unite libertarians and socialistsA plan to fight high drug prices that could unite libertarians and socialists
The Big Idea

First, attack monopolies. Second, replace patents with prizes.

By Charles Silver and David A. Hyman
The Big Idea
Family separation isn’t just immoral. It’s likely ineffective.Family separation isn’t just immoral. It’s likely ineffective.
The Big Idea

Deterrence tactics have dominated our border for decades. We’re still not sure if they work.

By Randy Capps
The Big Idea
To stop endless war, raise taxesTo stop endless war, raise taxes
The Big Idea

Until the public has to pay for war, it won’t demand peace.

By Sarah Kreps
The Big Idea
How to really watch the World CupHow to really watch the World Cup
The Big Idea

A trip inside the memory palace of the beautiful game.

By Laurent Dubois
The Big Idea
The Second Amendment allows for more gun control than you thinkThe Second Amendment allows for more gun control than you think
The Big Idea

We’re approaching the 10th anniversary of the Supreme Court’s landmark Heller decision. It didn’t cause a revolution in gun laws.

By Joseph Blocher and Eric Ruben
The mind, explained
We need new ways of treating depressionWe need new ways of treating depression
The mind, explained

Experts are now looking to the social and environmental causes of the disorder affecting millions.

By Johann Hari
The Big Idea
A human head transplant would be reckless and ghastly. It’s time to talk about it.A human head transplant would be reckless and ghastly. It’s time to talk about it.
The Big Idea

Two surgeons based in China say such surgery is “imminent.”

By Paul Root Wolpe
The Big Idea
NASA’s leader wants to privatize the International Space Station. It’s a terrible idea.NASA’s leader wants to privatize the International Space Station. It’s a terrible idea.
The Big Idea

There’s a case for killing the space station. There’s no case for turning over the keys to a private company.

By Konstantin Kakaes
The Big Idea
Trump’s legal attack on the ACA isn’t about health care. It’s a war on the rule of law.Trump’s legal attack on the ACA isn’t about health care. It’s a war on the rule of law.
The Big Idea

This flagrant violation of his constitutional duty should worry all Americans.

By Nicholas Bagley
The Big Idea
The new US policy of separating immigrant children from their parents has chilling historical echoesThe new US policy of separating immigrant children from their parents has chilling historical echoes
The Big Idea

America has never treated families — nonwhite families, anyway — as sacrosanct.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
The record-low birthrate offers yet another sign that millennials are economically screwedThe record-low birthrate offers yet another sign that millennials are economically screwed
The Big Idea

Would you have kids if you were drowning in debt?

By Alex Press
The Big Idea
A worried mom wanted the police to take her mentally ill son to the hospital. They shot him.A worried mom wanted the police to take her mentally ill son to the hospital. They shot him.
The Big Idea

When the police get asked to handle mental health crises, the results can be tragic.

By Alisa Roth
The Big Idea
Why is Elon Musk raging at “big media”? Because he’s finally being called on his tall tales.Why is Elon Musk raging at “big media”? Because he’s finally being called on his tall tales.
The Big Idea

All founders need to tell compelling stories about the future. Tesla’s Musk takes things to a whole new level.

By Brent Goldfarb and David Kirsch
The Big Idea
Demanding public rights in private spaces: lessons of the Starbucks controversyDemanding public rights in private spaces: lessons of the Starbucks controversy
The Big Idea

More and more “public” space is under corporate control. That affects how we interact as citizens.

By Bradley L. Garrett
The Big Idea
Many feminists find Philip Roth’s work off-putting. Elaine Showalter thinks he’s a titan.Many feminists find Philip Roth’s work off-putting. Elaine Showalter thinks he’s a titan.
The Big Idea

Showalter has been reading — and loving — Roth since 1959.

By Christopher Shea
The Big Idea
The NFL’s “take a knee” ban is flatly illegalThe NFL’s “take a knee” ban is flatly illegal
The Big Idea

It violates labor law and, most likely, players’ free speech rights.

By Benjamin Sachs
The Big Idea
A radical proposal to fight poverty in the developing world: tax the rich more than the poorA radical proposal to fight poverty in the developing world: tax the rich more than the poor
The Big Idea

No, really.

By Charles Kenny and Justin Sandefur
The Big Idea
Europe’s tough new digital privacy law should be a model for US policymakersEurope’s tough new digital privacy law should be a model for US policymakers
The Big Idea

The General Data Protection Regulation Act, or GDPR, enshrines data protection as a fundamental human right

By Trevor Butterworth
The Big Idea
How domestic abusers use smartphones to spy on their partnersHow domestic abusers use smartphones to spy on their partners
The Big Idea

There’s more creepy spyware out there than you think — and regulating it is a legal and technological challenge.

By Nicki Dell, Karen Levy, Damon McCoy, and Thomas Ristenpart
The Big Idea
The government prosecution of a “black identity extremist” fell apart. Meanwhile, white supremacists are on the march.The government prosecution of a “black identity extremist” fell apart. Meanwhile, white supremacists are on the march.
The Big Idea

It fits a pattern: US officials have historically found black radicals far more threatening than white supremacists.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
Steven Pinker’s new book on the Enlightenment is a huge hit. Too bad it gets the Enlightenment wrong.Steven Pinker’s new book on the Enlightenment is a huge hit. Too bad it gets the Enlightenment wrong.
The Big Idea

Pinker’s hyper-optimism and faith in progress have little to do with the actual views of Enlightenment thinkers. Scholars who point that out aren’t enemies of Western civilization.

By Aaron R. Hanlon
The Big Idea
Trump and Obama both ignored Gaza — at great costTrump and Obama both ignored Gaza — at great cost
The Big Idea

The extremist group Hamas wants to fill the void in Palestinian leadership. US abandonment of the peace process has furthered its goal.

By Daniel Byman
The Big Idea
The Republican cold war on the Affordable Care ActThe Republican cold war on the Affordable Care Act
The Big Idea

The GOP is still working hard to dismantle affordable health care. They’re just doing it more quietly, argues a former top official at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

By Andy Slavitt
The Big Idea
Support for working moms is stronger than ever —  except when it comes to parental leave and other concrete policiesSupport for working moms is stronger than ever —  except when it comes to parental leave and other concrete policies
The Big Idea

Far more than its peer countries, the US forces mothers to choose between work and time with kids.

By Lyman Stone
The Big Idea
The “Intellectual Dark Web,” explained: what Jordan Peterson has in common with the alt-rightThe “Intellectual Dark Web,” explained: what Jordan Peterson has in common with the alt-right
The Big Idea

A controversial New York Times article describes several popular white intellectuals as marginalized “renegades.”

By Henry Farrell
The Big Idea
Trump has put the US on a path to bombing IranTrump has put the US on a path to bombing Iran
The Big Idea

He’s undercut diplomacy. The predictable next step: a steady drumbeat of calls for a military strike.

By Michael Krepon
The Big Idea
It’s time for liberals to get over Citizens UnitedIt’s time for liberals to get over Citizens United
The Big Idea

Repealing the controversial decision is a pipe dream. And there are more promising avenues for campaign-finance reform.

By Scott Casleton
The Big Idea
The hearings for Trump’s CIA pick should prompt a reckoning with tortureThe hearings for Trump’s CIA pick should prompt a reckoning with torture
The Big Idea

There’s much we don’t know about her role at a notorious “black site” where torture occurred — and about the role of other US officials.

By Karen J. Greenberg
The Big Idea
The Golden State Killer case shows how swiftly we’re losing genetic privacyThe Golden State Killer case shows how swiftly we’re losing genetic privacy
The Big Idea

Someone may be scrutinizing your genome right now, due to sites like 23andMe, police investigations, and hackers.

By Norman A. Paradis
The Big Idea
How low can unemployment go? Economists keep getting the answer wrong.How low can unemployment go? Economists keep getting the answer wrong.
The Big Idea

The April jobs report adds to the debate about whether a “natural” rate of unemployment exists.

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
The racial demons that help explain evangelical support for TrumpThe racial demons that help explain evangelical support for Trump
The Big Idea

Some conservatives struggle to understand why Christians embrace the president. If they knew their history, they’d be less shocked.

By Nancy D. Wadsworth