Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

How reliable is fingerprint analysis?

Fingerprint analysis can be useful for law enforcement, but it’s not as reliable as you think.

Fingerprint analysis is used by law enforcement in most parts of the world. Here in the United States, the fingerprint database has more than 100 million subjects on file that police can cross-check when a print is left at a crime scene.

Fingerprints have many unique features that differentiate them from everyone else’s, and analysts look for these features when comparing two prints. By finding similar patterns and noting any differences they’re able to determine whether they have a positive match or not. But how reliable are these comparisons?

It turns out that there’s room for error. One accuracy study found that analysts make false positive matches (saying two prints are the same when they’re not) in 0.1% of cases. That may seem pretty good, but it can be a huge problem when an innocent person is wrongfully convicted of a crime based on a false match.

Watch the video above to learn how Brandon Mayfield, an American lawyer, was accused of the 2004 Madrid train bombing based on faulty fingerprint analysis. Subscribe to our YouTube channel to view all of our latest videos.

More in Video

Video
Why Americans can’t escape credit card debtWhy Americans can’t escape credit card debt
Play
Video

Credit card APRs are now as high as 20 percent.

By Frank Posillico
Video
Why some couples are happier living apartWhy some couples are happier living apart
Play
Video

This growing relationship trend might change the way you think about living with your romantic partner.

By Gina Pollack
Video
The strange myth behind carrots and night visionThe strange myth behind carrots and night vision
Play
Video

How we fell for World War II propaganda.

By Nate Krieger
Video
Are team sports the secret to living longer?Are team sports the secret to living longer?
Play
Video

How a basketball league for “grannies” is reimagining aging.

By Benjamin Stephen
Video
How Georgia manufactured the Peach State mythHow Georgia manufactured the Peach State myth
Play
Video

It was never really about the fruit.

By Frank Posillico
Video
How smart design can benefit senior livingHow smart design can benefit senior living
Play
Video

And why it matters for retirement communities.

By Lindsey Sitz