Skip to main content

The Big Idea

Outside contributors’ opinions and analysis of the most important issues in politics, science, and culture.

The Big Idea
The Logan Paul YouTube controversy and what we should expect from internet platformsThe Logan Paul YouTube controversy and what we should expect from internet platforms
The Big Idea

When users abuse a platform, who is responsible?

By Tarleton Gillespie
The Big Idea
Here’s how immigrants from countries Trump slammed really do in the USHere’s how immigrants from countries Trump slammed really do in the US
The Big Idea

Even within programs designed to help victims of crisis, the US skims off top performers.

By Lyman Stone
The Big Idea
#MeToo is not a witch hunt#MeToo is not a witch hunt
The Big Idea

America has a rich history of moral panics. This isn’t one.

By Richard Beck
The Big Idea
What these early-20th-century scholars got right about 21st-century politicsWhat these early-20th-century scholars got right about 21st-century politics
The Big Idea

Unlike many economists today, they questioned fundamental social structure.

By Branko Milanovic
The Big Idea
How to think about consuming art made by sexual predators.How to think about consuming art made by sexual predators.
The Big Idea

Platforms are busily pulling shows and movies. But viewers still face tough moral and aesthetic decisions.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
James Damore has sued Google. His infamous memo on women in tech is still nonsense.James Damore has sued Google. His infamous memo on women in tech is still nonsense.
The Big Idea

Don’t be taken in by the document’s faux-reasonable tone.

By Cynthia Lee
The Big Idea
9 ways the world got a lot better in 20179 ways the world got a lot better in 2017
The Big Idea

It seemed awful. But overall, it was a great year for humanity.

By Charles Kenny
The Big Idea
There are problems with the Republican tax bill. Deficits aren’t one of them.There are problems with the Republican tax bill. Deficits aren’t one of them.
The Big Idea

With borrowing rates so low, deficit-financed stimulus might be just what’s called for.

By Karl Smith and Samuel Hammond
The Big Idea
Groping is a crimeGroping is a crime
The Big Idea

In many states, unwanted touching isn’t just boorish. It’s illegal.

By Joanna L. Grossman
The Big Idea
There is no 1st Amendment right to speak on a college campusThere is no 1st Amendment right to speak on a college campus
The Big Idea

What almost everyone gets wrong about the campus free speech debate.

By Robert C. Post
The Big Idea
Donald Trump is a dangerously weak presidentDonald Trump is a dangerously weak president
The Big Idea

The media is crediting him with a tax overhaul victory. But he still holds remarkably little clout in Washington.

By Matthew Glassman
The Big Idea
Hate speech is protected free speech, even on college campusesHate speech is protected free speech, even on college campuses
The Big Idea

My students trust colleges to control offensive speech. They shouldn’t.

By Erwin Chemerinsky
The Big Idea
7 ways rich people can game the Republican tax plan, explained by a tax expert7 ways rich people can game the Republican tax plan, explained by a tax expert
The Big Idea

For many, the 37 percent top rate is just an opening bid.

By Ari Glogower
The Big Idea
“Neoliberalism” isn’t an empty epithet. It’s a real, powerful set of ideas.“Neoliberalism” isn’t an empty epithet. It’s a real, powerful set of ideas.
The Big Idea

The word captures something crucial about the faction that took over the Democratic Party after Reagan.

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
The tax bill destroys an important part of Obamacare. The states can save it.The tax bill destroys an important part of Obamacare. The states can save it.
The Big Idea

States don’t have to stand by and watch the ACA implode.

By Nicholas Bagley
The Big Idea
How could Roy Moore win? Because parties are weak and partisanship is strong.How could Roy Moore win? Because parties are weak and partisanship is strong.
The Big Idea

Republican elites lost control of the primary, and rank-and-file voters don’t care.

By Julia Azari
The Big Idea
How Trump’s reckless climate policy invites a judicial backlashHow Trump’s reckless climate policy invites a judicial backlash
The Big Idea

The worst way to do policy is through the courts. But that could be where we’re headed.

By David Bookbinder
The Big Idea
The left shouldn’t make peace with neocons — even to defeat TrumpThe left shouldn’t make peace with neocons — even to defeat Trump
The Big Idea

Don’t trust “woke Bill Kristol.”

By Robert Wright
The Big Idea
The GOP is trying to pass a super-unpopular agenda — and that’s a bad sign for democracyThe GOP is trying to pass a super-unpopular agenda — and that’s a bad sign for democracy
The Big Idea

Political science (and common sense) says they ought to pay a price at the polls. They might not.

By Jacob S. Hacker and Paul Pierson
The Big Idea
Masterpiece Cakeshop and how “religious liberty” became so toxicMasterpiece Cakeshop and how “religious liberty” became so toxic
The Big Idea

The right went too far with Masterpiece Cakeshop. But liberals need not fear reasonable religious exemptions.

By Andrew Koppelman
The Big Idea
We’re lawyers who support same-sex marriage. We also support the Masterpiece Cakeshop baker.We’re lawyers who support same-sex marriage. We also support the Masterpiece Cakeshop baker.
The Big Idea

Same-sex marriage and religious liberty can coexist.

By Douglas Laycock and Thomas C. Berg
The Big Idea
Vice President Pence’s “never dine alone with a woman” rule isn’t honorable. It’s probably illegal.Vice President Pence’s “never dine alone with a woman” rule isn’t honorable. It’s probably illegal.
The Big Idea

An employment lawyer weighs in.

By Joanna L. Grossman
The Big Idea
Under Trump, Democrats have been shut out of policymaking. That’s about to change.Under Trump, Democrats have been shut out of policymaking. That’s about to change.
The Big Idea

They have an opening to protect DREAMers and strengthen the ACA. They must seize it.

By Ron Pollack
The Big Idea
#MeToo’s roots in the feminist awakening of the 1960s#MeToo’s roots in the feminist awakening of the 1960s
The Big Idea

Women turned a place rife with abuse into the base of a social movement. It’s not the first time.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
How much of your online life should police have access to? SCOTUS prepares to weigh in.How much of your online life should police have access to? SCOTUS prepares to weigh in.
The Big Idea

Oral arguments begin Wednesday over updating the Fourth Amendment for a smartphone world.

By Hannah Bloch-Wehba
The Big Idea
How segregation leads to racist voting by whitesHow segregation leads to racist voting by whites
The Big Idea

Political scientists use new tools — and draw on psychology — to explain how and why “social geography” shapes attitudes.

By Ryan D. Enos
The Big Idea
“We are not recommending you give to Texas per se”: GiveDirectly’s bold disaster-relief experiment“We are not recommending you give to Texas per se”: GiveDirectly’s bold disaster-relief experiment
The Big Idea

Why a charity focused on giving cash to East Africa started working near Houston.

By Dylan Matthews
The Big Idea
Republicans can repeal Obamacare. They can’t repeal the logic of health insurance.Republicans can repeal Obamacare. They can’t repeal the logic of health insurance.
The Big Idea

Some people must pay more than is “fair.”

By Uwe Reinhardt
The Big Idea
Age-of-consent laws don’t reflect teenage psychology. Here’s how to fix them.Age-of-consent laws don’t reflect teenage psychology. Here’s how to fix them.
The Big Idea

The concept of “revocable assent” would massively increase the risks for predators.

By Jennifer A. Drobac
The Big Idea
The Menendez trial revealed everything that’s gone wrong with US bribery lawThe Menendez trial revealed everything that’s gone wrong with US bribery law
The Big Idea

Blame the Supreme Court

By Zephyr Teachout
The Big Idea
Republicans are weaponizing the tax codeRepublicans are weaponizing the tax code
The Big Idea

They’re rewarding capital, punishing labor — and dismantling the tax code welfare state.

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
The US needs more babies, more immigrants, and more integrationThe US needs more babies, more immigrants, and more integration
The Big Idea

Yes, we should increase fertility. But that doesn’t mean we should stop welcoming foreigners.

By Lyman Stone
The Big Idea
The “virgin vote”: a historian discovers why young Americans once actually votedThe “virgin vote”: a historian discovers why young Americans once actually voted
The Big Idea

In the mid-1800s, politics were indispensable to making friends, becoming an adult, and even getting laid.

By Jeff Stein
The Big Idea
How issuing pardons could end Trump’s presidencyHow issuing pardons could end Trump’s presidency
The Big Idea

Some allies say Trump should exercise the pardon power to shut down a “biased” investigation. Here’s how that could backfire.

By Vinay Nayak and Samuel Breidbart
The Big Idea
The GOP says its business tax plan will help workers and small businesses. It won’t.The GOP says its business tax plan will help workers and small businesses. It won’t.
The Big Idea

Instead, it’s a gift to people with lots of capital.

By Edward Kleinbard
The Big Idea
6 ways climate change and disease helped topple the Roman Empire6 ways climate change and disease helped topple the Roman Empire
The Big Idea

New scholarship on Rome reminds us of the fragility of human societies in the face of nature.

By Kyle Harper
The Big Idea
The “foreign agents” law Paul Manafort is charged with breaking is wildly underenforcedThe “foreign agents” law Paul Manafort is charged with breaking is wildly underenforced
The Big Idea

It relies on voluntary compliance — which basically invites lobbyists to flout the law.

By Lydia Dennett
The Big Idea
The real cost of the Republican tax cutsThe real cost of the Republican tax cuts
The Big Idea

They’ll require spending cuts, or tax increases in other areas. Either could hurt many American families.

By Jason Furman and Greg Leiserson
The Big Idea
As a campaign manager faces charges, the Trump-Nixon parallel gets strongerAs a campaign manager faces charges, the Trump-Nixon parallel gets stronger
The Big Idea

John Mitchell ended up in jail. Will Paul Manafort?

By Amy Fried
The Big Idea
Republican elites cheered the right-wing insurgency. Now it’s coming for them.Republican elites cheered the right-wing insurgency. Now it’s coming for them.
The Big Idea

It’s not just about Trump. Power has shifted markedly toward non-elected figures like Steve Bannon and Sean Hannity.

By David A. Hopkins