Skip to main content

The Big Idea

Outside contributors’ opinions and analysis of the most important issues in politics, science, and culture.

The Big Idea
So you’ve learned you’ve got a “pitifully” low IQ. How worried should you be?So you’ve learned you’ve got a “pitifully” low IQ. How worried should you be?
The Big Idea

IQ is real, it’s important, and it’s also unreliable on the individual level.

By Scott Alexander
The Big Idea
Trump’s economists say a corporate tax cut will raise wages by $4,000. It doesn’t add up.Trump’s economists say a corporate tax cut will raise wages by $4,000. It doesn’t add up.
The Big Idea

The UK cut corporate rates and wages still dropped.

By Kimberly Clausing and Edward Kleinbard
The Big Idea
Sexism and male voyeurism have been intertwined throughout movie historySexism and male voyeurism have been intertwined throughout movie history
The Big Idea

Harvey Weinstein and the male cinematic gaze.

By David Thomson
The Big Idea
This year’s economics Nobel winner invented a tool that’s both brilliant and undemocraticThis year’s economics Nobel winner invented a tool that’s both brilliant and undemocratic
The Big Idea

“Nudges” aren’t good for democracy.

By Henry Farrell
The Big Idea
Benching NFL players for protesting during the anthem would be illegalBenching NFL players for protesting during the anthem would be illegal
The Big Idea

The owner of the Dallas Cowboys has sworn to do so.

By Benjamin Sachs
The Big Idea
How nondisclosure agreements protect sexual predatorsHow nondisclosure agreements protect sexual predators
The Big Idea

Some kinds of non-disclosure agreements appear to violate federal law.

By Daniel Hemel
The Big Idea
Could we reverse a hacked presidential election?Could we reverse a hacked presidential election?
The Big Idea

The Constitution provides no clear answer — and we need a solution.

By Vinay Nayak and Samuel Breidbart
The Big Idea
Does the anti-gerrymandering campaign threaten minority voting rights?Does the anti-gerrymandering campaign threaten minority voting rights?
The Big Idea

We tested the theory — which has been put forward by both Democrats and Republicans.

By Michael Li and Laura Royden
The Big Idea
Even the intellectual left is drawn to conspiracy theories about the right. Resist them.Even the intellectual left is drawn to conspiracy theories about the right. Resist them.
The Big Idea

How not to write about “radical” libertarians.

By Henry Farrell and Steven Teles
The Big Idea
“Mindful resistance” is the key to defeating Trump“Mindful resistance” is the key to defeating Trump
The Big Idea

Outrage and disdain waste mental energy and feed into the narrative that sustains the president.

By Robert Wright
The Big Idea
How colonialism and racism explain the inept US response to Hurricane MariaHow colonialism and racism explain the inept US response to Hurricane Maria
The Big Idea

US senator, 1898: Puerto Ricans can’t govern themselves. President Trump, 2017: They “want everything done for them.”

By Carrie Gibson
The Big Idea
The Republican tax “plan” is a deficit-busting mess. And it would slash the president’s taxes.The Republican tax “plan” is a deficit-busting mess. And it would slash the president’s taxes.
The Big Idea

It skimps on crucial details. But we know who will benefit.

By Edward Kleinbard
The Big Idea
Republican rhetoric about giving states “flexibility” over health care is a shamRepublican rhetoric about giving states “flexibility” over health care is a sham
The Big Idea

The GOP extols a fake kind of “federalism.”

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
Cory Booker has a plan to “reverse” mass incarceration. It won’t work.Cory Booker has a plan to “reverse” mass incarceration. It won’t work.
The Big Idea

The bill will create powerful opponents among prison guards and prosecutors

By John Pfaff
The Big Idea
What the Constitution says Berkeley can do when controversial speakers come knockingWhat the Constitution says Berkeley can do when controversial speakers come knocking
The Big Idea

The rules governing the right-wing “Free Speech Week” showdown.

By Mark Tushnet
The Big Idea
Steve Bannon is right: the Catholic Church “needs” illegal immigrantsSteve Bannon is right: the Catholic Church “needs” illegal immigrants
The Big Idea

There is no “Christian position” on immigration. But religious leaders’ duty to vulnerable people is clear.

By Lyman Stone
The Big Idea
The women fighting for white male supremacyThe women fighting for white male supremacy
The Big Idea

A few women seek leadership roles on the alt-right. It’s tricky.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
Wages are stagnating, robots are taking our jobs. This Democrat has a $1.4 trillion solution.Wages are stagnating, robots are taking our jobs. This Democrat has a $1.4 trillion solution.
The Big Idea

He wants to give a major boost to the Earned Income Tax Credit.

By Greg Ferenstein
The Big Idea
Illegal immigration challenges the rule of law. But Trump is making things worse.Illegal immigration challenges the rule of law. But Trump is making things worse.
The Big Idea

A crackdown on DREAMers will undermine respect for the law, not shore it up.

By David A. Martin
The Big Idea
I ran ACA outreach under Obama. Trump’s funding cuts could ruin the health care law.I ran ACA outreach under Obama. Trump’s funding cuts could ruin the health care law.
The Big Idea

The data shows that advertising drives enrollment.

By Lori Lodes
The Big Idea
Single-payer isn’t the only progressive option on health careSingle-payer isn’t the only progressive option on health care
The Big Idea

There are several routes to universal coverage — some more politically feasible than others.

By Ron Pollack
The Big Idea
The irrational way people calculate hurricane risksThe irrational way people calculate hurricane risks
The Big Idea

They focus too much on the last storm they experienced.

By Wanyun Shao and Siyuan Xian
The Big Idea
We need political parties. But their rabid partisanship could destroy American democracy.We need political parties. But their rabid partisanship could destroy American democracy.
The Big Idea

We’re trapped in a frightening “doom loop” of mutual distrust.

By Lee Drutman
The Big Idea
How bosses are (literally) like dictatorsHow bosses are (literally) like dictators
The Big Idea

Americans think they live in a democracy. But their workplaces are small tyrannies.

By Elizabeth Anderson
The Big Idea
The right to organize at work deserves constitutional protectionThe right to organize at work deserves constitutional protection
The Big Idea

Courts have for too long tied the hands of workers who dare to criticize their employers.

By Shaun Richman
The Big Idea
The Summer of Love ended 50 years ago. It reshaped American conservatism.The Summer of Love ended 50 years ago. It reshaped American conservatism.
The Big Idea

The Jesus People reshaped both American Christianity and conservatism.

By Neil J. Young
The Big Idea
Well-off “helicopter” parents are super annoying, but they didn’t create economic inequalityWell-off “helicopter” parents are super annoying, but they didn’t create economic inequality
The Big Idea

A new analysis takes the focus off the top 1 percent and ignores deeper structural problems.

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
Artificial wombs are coming. They could completely change the debate over abortion.Artificial wombs are coming. They could completely change the debate over abortion.
The Big Idea

If a fetus can be transferred to a fabricated womb, can the right to abortion survive?

By I. Glenn Cohen
The Big Idea
“Medicare for all” is Democrats’ new rallying cry. “Medicaid for more” would be even better.“Medicare for all” is Democrats’ new rallying cry. “Medicaid for more” would be even better.
The Big Idea

Medicaid just saved the ACA. Let’s build on it.

By Michael S. Sparer
The Big Idea
We conservatives champion local power. So we must respect the rights of “blue” cities.We conservatives champion local power. So we must respect the rights of “blue” cities.
The Big Idea

Giving states and cities more power is one solution to polarization.

By Lyman Stone
The Big Idea
I’ve studied the history of Confederate memorials. Here’s what to do about them.I’ve studied the history of Confederate memorials. Here’s what to do about them.
The Big Idea

Many were funded privately. The public now deserves a say in their fate.

By W. Fitzhugh Brundage
The Big Idea
Why this happened in Charlottesville, my hometownWhy this happened in Charlottesville, my hometown
The Big Idea

The city can look like a blue bubble, but it’s full of conflicts and contradictions.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
National revulsion over the Charlottesville march shows why we shouldn’t ban hate speechNational revulsion over the Charlottesville march shows why we shouldn’t ban hate speech
The Big Idea

Neo-Nazis have been denied the chance to claim their views are suppressed. Americans are rendering their verdict.

By Robert C. Post
The Big Idea
Who’s truly rebuilding the Democratic Party? The activists.Who’s truly rebuilding the Democratic Party? The activists.
The Big Idea

From health care to full employment to college affordability, they’re out ahead of the politicians.

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
We have a political problem no one wants to talk about: very old politiciansWe have a political problem no one wants to talk about: very old politicians
The Big Idea

Death, disability, and mental impairment are among the statistically predictable risks.

By Harold Pollack
The Big Idea
There’s no evidence that immigrants hurt any American workersThere’s no evidence that immigrants hurt any American workers
The Big Idea

The debate over the Mariel boatlift, a crucial immigration case study, explained.

By Michael Clemens
The Big Idea
Medicaid saved the Affordable Care Act. Liberals should take notice.Medicaid saved the Affordable Care Act. Liberals should take notice.
The Big Idea

“Targeted” aid programs can have staying power.

By Mark Schmitt
The Big Idea
Trump’s ominous threat to withhold payment from health insurers, explainedTrump’s ominous threat to withhold payment from health insurers, explained
The Big Idea

Congress could just appropriate the money. But Trump and Paul Ryan want a cudgel to use against Democrats.

By Nicholas Bagley
The Big Idea
Why Tesla is overhyped — and overvaluedWhy Tesla is overhyped — and overvalued
The Big Idea

It’s not clear what Elon Musk is disrupting.

By Brent Goldfarb
The Big Idea
A surprising amount of medical research isn’t made public. That’s dangerous.A surprising amount of medical research isn’t made public. That’s dangerous.
The Big Idea

The practice continues despite a federal law mandating research transparency.

By Stephanie Wykstra