Skip to main content

The Big Idea

Outside contributors’ opinions and analysis of the most important issues in politics, science, and culture.

The Big Idea
This voting reform solves 2 of America’s biggest political problemsThis voting reform solves 2 of America’s biggest political problems
The Big Idea

“Proportional” voting would reduce party polarization and the number of wasted votes.

By Lee Drutman
The Big Idea
Democrats with dreams of impeachment should consider how Iran-Contra turned outDemocrats with dreams of impeachment should consider how Iran-Contra turned out
The Big Idea

The investigation brought indictments and convictions — but little long-term damage to Reagan.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
Why adoption plays such a big, contentious role in US-Russia relationsWhy adoption plays such a big, contentious role in US-Russia relations
The Big Idea

As demand in the US for children to adopt surged, Russian officials focused on cases of abuse and neglect.

By Kathryn Joyce
The Big Idea
The real parallel between Nixon and Trump: backdoor pre-election contacts with a foreign powerThe real parallel between Nixon and Trump: backdoor pre-election contacts with a foreign power
The Big Idea

LBJ agonized over whether to reveal Nixon’s backchannel diplomacy.

By John A. Farrell
The Big Idea
The Russia connections may yet bring Trump down. But right now critics are crying wolf.The Russia connections may yet bring Trump down. But right now critics are crying wolf.
The Big Idea
Mainline churches are emptying. The political effects could be huge.Mainline churches are emptying. The political effects could be huge.
The Big Idea

When people leave churches, do they drift toward Trumpist populism?

By Lyman Stone
The Big Idea
What a good conservative health care plan would look likeWhat a good conservative health care plan would look like
The Big Idea

The Better Care Reconciliation Act fails to fix the flaws of Obamacare that conservatives most often complain about.

By Ed Dolan
The Big Idea
The research that convinced SCOTUS to take the Wisconsin gerrymandering case, explainedThe research that convinced SCOTUS to take the Wisconsin gerrymandering case, explained
The Big Idea

Researchers wield a new tool called the “efficiency gap” to put Wisconsin’s district map into context — nationally and historically.

By Nicholas Stephanopoulos
The Big Idea
Anne Frank, and America’s dangerously shallow understanding of the HolocaustAnne Frank, and America’s dangerously shallow understanding of the Holocaust
The Big Idea

It’s treated as an all-purpose symbol of evil, not a series of historical events to be reckoned with.

By Andrea Pitzer
The Big Idea
What the stock market’s rise under Trump should teach DemocratsWhat the stock market’s rise under Trump should teach Democrats
The Big Idea

Wall Street shrugs off Trump’s recklessness and unpredictability. There’s a lesson in that.

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
Fake news is bad. Attempts to ban it are worse.Fake news is bad. Attempts to ban it are worse.
The Big Idea

The US shouldn’t follow Europe’s lead in seeking to criminalize bogus reports.

By Anthony L. Fisher
The Big Idea
208,500 additional deaths could occur by 2026 under the Senate health plan208,500 additional deaths could occur by 2026 under the Senate health plan
The Big Idea

Analysts who say health insurance doesn’t affect mortality are wrong.

By Ann Crawford-Roberts, Nichole Roxas, and Ichiro Kawachi
The Big Idea
How the Trump administration’s secrecy could inspire long-needed transparency reformsHow the Trump administration’s secrecy could inspire long-needed transparency reforms
The Big Idea

He’s adding a dark chapter to the modern history of presidential concealment of information.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
SCOTUS ruled that churches qualify for state money. Churches, beware.SCOTUS ruled that churches qualify for state money. Churches, beware.
The Big Idea

For churches, state money can be a poison pill.

By Lyman Stone
The Big Idea
Crazy waivers: the Senate bill invites states to gut important health insurance rulesCrazy waivers: the Senate bill invites states to gut important health insurance rules
The Big Idea

A little-noticed provision could be a stalking horse for further dismantling of the health care system.

By Nicholas Bagley
The Big Idea
The Senate’s disastrous process for crafting the AHCA fits a historic patternThe Senate’s disastrous process for crafting the AHCA fits a historic pattern
The Big Idea

The House and Senate have been holding fewer and fewer hearings on policy issues since the 1970s — and they’re less substantive.

By Jonathan Lewallen, Sean M. Theriault, and Bryan D. Jones
The Big Idea
How to stop cruel factory farming: start with one animalHow to stop cruel factory farming: start with one animal
The Big Idea

People have irrational sympathy for cows and pigs. Animal rights activists should appeal to that impulse.

By Brian Kateman
The Big Idea
There’s still no good reason to believe black-white IQ differences are due to genesThere’s still no good reason to believe black-white IQ differences are due to genes
The Big Idea

Our response to criticisms.

By Eric Turkheimer, Kathryn Paige Harden, and Richard E. Nisbett
The Big Idea
Lawmakers across the US are finding ways to turn protesting into a crimeLawmakers across the US are finding ways to turn protesting into a crime
The Big Idea

Efforts range from charging people for the costs of policing to making “boisterous” actions an offense.

By Ruthann Robson
The Big Idea
It’s now clear US voting is hackable. Here are 6 things we must do to prevent chaos.It’s now clear US voting is hackable. Here are 6 things we must do to prevent chaos.
The Big Idea

Several bombshell news reports this month reveal our vulnerability.

By Suzanne Mello-Stark
The Big Idea
The case that President Trump committed the crime of obstruction of justice, explainedThe case that President Trump committed the crime of obstruction of justice, explained
The Big Idea

It’s not open and shut, but a constitutional scholar says the evidence is mounting.

By Daniel Hemel
The Big Idea
It’s time to explode the myth of “McJobs”It’s time to explode the myth of “McJobs”
The Big Idea

Pessimists on the left describe a future of dead-end jobs and robot workers. They’re wrong.

By Ruy Teixeira
The Big Idea
Women have been drugged and raped by men for centuries. This medieval woman fought back — and won.Women have been drugged and raped by men for centuries. This medieval woman fought back — and won.
The Big Idea

A lesson for the Cosby trial?

By Carissa Harris
The Big Idea
Why didn’t he quit — or fight back? Senators treated Comey like a sexual harassment victim.Why didn’t he quit — or fight back? Senators treated Comey like a sexual harassment victim.
The Big Idea

Comey’s hearing hit almost all the familiar tropes of how those who allege sexual harassment are treated.

By Corrine McConnaughy
The Big Idea
Like expensive bank bailouts? You’ll love the financial bill the House just passed.Like expensive bank bailouts? You’ll love the financial bill the House just passed.
The Big Idea

It knocks out two pillars of post-2008 financial reform.

By Jonah Crane
Politics
Trump’s Paris climate agreement speech, annotated by an expert in energy and foreign policyTrump’s Paris climate agreement speech, annotated by an expert in energy and foreign policy
Politics

Practically every paragraph is rooted in a falsehood.

By David Victor
The Big Idea
We need to think harder about terrorism and gender. ISIS already is.We need to think harder about terrorism and gender. ISIS already is.
The Big Idea

The extremist group tailors its recruitment messages to women and justifies attacks on young girls.

By Heather Hurlburt and Jacqueline O'Neill
The Big Idea
Sorry, kids: schools need more testing, not lessSorry, kids: schools need more testing, not less
The Big Idea

Done right, tests can do more than evaluate: They can teach.

By Ulrich Boser
The Big Idea
Voting rights are under assault nationwide. Here’s how to protect them.Voting rights are under assault nationwide. Here’s how to protect them.
The Big Idea

A new Voting Rights Act could target the wave of state-level vote suppression.

By Russ Feingold
The Big Idea
Free Robert Mueller: here’s how to make his investigation truly independentFree Robert Mueller: here’s how to make his investigation truly independent
The Big Idea

Trump’s Justice Department still has way too much control over the Russia investigation.

By Daniel Hemel
The Big Idea
It may be time to disobey the commander in chiefIt may be time to disobey the commander in chief
The Big Idea

With his assault on the rule of law, President Trump has undermined his legitimacy.

By Will Wilkinson
The Big Idea
Trump’s budget assumes 3 percent annual growth. Why that’s extremely unlikely, explained.Trump’s budget assumes 3 percent annual growth. Why that’s extremely unlikely, explained.
The Big Idea

Policy has a limited ability to make a difference.

By Jason Furman
The Big Idea
Forcing out unwanted FBI directors: a brief, messy historyForcing out unwanted FBI directors: a brief, messy history
The Big Idea

Except for J. Edgar Hoover, history shows the position rarely comes with job security.

By Rhodri Jeffreys-Jones
The Big Idea
What right-wing populism? Polls reveal that it’s liberalism that’s surging.What right-wing populism? Polls reveal that it’s liberalism that’s surging.
The Big Idea

From immigration to the role of government, there’s a continuing shift toward liberal views.

By Ruy Teixeira
The Big Idea
Roger Ailes’s legacy: the road to the White House runs through Fox NewsRoger Ailes’s legacy: the road to the White House runs through Fox News
The Big Idea

The media innovator built a network that anoints presidents and ignores scandals.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
Charles Murray is once again peddling junk science about race and IQCharles Murray is once again peddling junk science about race and IQ
The Big Idea

Podcaster and author Sam Harris is the latest to fall for it.

By Eric Turkheimer, Kathryn Paige Harden, and Richard E. Nisbett
The Big Idea
A forgotten lesson of Watergate: conservatives may rally around TrumpA forgotten lesson of Watergate: conservatives may rally around Trump
The Big Idea

Like Trump, Nixon was distrusted by the right — until the press picked up the scent of Watergate.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
The US is terrible at investigating politicians. Blame the Constitution.The US is terrible at investigating politicians. Blame the Constitution.
The Big Idea

South Africa and Brazil, among others, could give the US tips.

By Mark Tushnet
The Big Idea
The Bush administration fired me from the Justice Department over politicsThe Bush administration fired me from the Justice Department over politics
The Big Idea

Bush paid a price for violating the department’s independence — and so should Trump.

By John McKay
The Big Idea
This is how democratic backsliding beginsThis is how democratic backsliding begins
The Big Idea

Coups are out. The erosion of the rule of law more typically occurs through the curbing of watchdog agencies.

By Aziz Huq