Skip to main content

The Big Idea

Outside contributors’ opinions and analysis of the most important issues in politics, science, and culture.

The Big Idea
Why the war on poverty failed — and what to do nowWhy the war on poverty failed — and what to do now
The Big Idea

Brooklyn’s Bedford-Stuyvesant was ground zero for Great Society anti-poverty programs. You’d hardly guess it today.

By John McWhorter
The Big Idea
Electoral integrity in all 50 US states, ranked by expertsElectoral integrity in all 50 US states, ranked by experts
The Big Idea

As a region, the South lags. But many states could improve how they conduct elections.

By Pippa Norris, Holly Ann Garnett, and Max Grömping
The Big Idea
Psychedelic experiences might “cure” smoking and OCD. Should we allow them?Psychedelic experiences might “cure” smoking and OCD. Should we allow them?
The Big Idea

Psychedelic drugs are back in a big way. Let’s get the policy right this time.

By Mark A.R. Kleiman
The Big Idea
Proof that life is getting better for humanity, in 5 chartsProof that life is getting better for humanity, in 5 charts
The Big Idea

A short-term perspective means we forget how much progress has been made in reducing poverty and mortality rates — and in much else.

By Max Roser
The Big Idea
Every US president promises to boost economic growth. The catch: no one knows how.Every US president promises to boost economic growth. The catch: no one knows how.
The Big Idea

Economic productivity dropped in the early ’70s and has never fully recovered

By Marc Levinson
The Big Idea
Republicans are about to learn just how much Americans hate health insurance changesRepublicans are about to learn just how much Americans hate health insurance changes
The Big Idea

They confront some of the same forces that bedeviled President Barack Obama’s reforms.

By Jon Kingsdale
The Big Idea
Make the Electoral College great again: let “conscientious electors” do their jobsMake the Electoral College great again: let “conscientious electors” do their jobs
The Big Idea

The founders didn’t expect electors to rubber-stamp the popular vote.

By Michael Signer
The Big Idea
The Electoral College magnifies the power of white votersThe Electoral College magnifies the power of white voters
The Big Idea

Voters in swing states are disproportionately white — a fact that shapes campaigns.

By Andrew Gelman and Pierre-Antoine Kremp
The Big Idea
Safety versus autonomy: advocates for autistic children split over tracking devicesSafety versus autonomy: advocates for autistic children split over tracking devices
The Big Idea

Children who “wander” can pose risks to themselves. But restricting freedom carries risks too.

By Ari Ne'eman
The Big Idea
Why David Brock’s plan to create a “Breitbart of the left” is destined to failWhy David Brock’s plan to create a “Breitbart of the left” is destined to fail
The Big Idea

Liberal efforts to mimic conservative media have a long, sad history.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
The voting rights manifesto: a state-by-state plan to defend democracyThe voting rights manifesto: a state-by-state plan to defend democracy
The Big Idea

Republicans are leading an assault on voting rights. Democrats need to go on the counterattack.

By Daniel Nichanian
The Big Idea
Current laws permitting assisted suicide are morally indefensibleCurrent laws permitting assisted suicide are morally indefensible
The Big Idea

Everyone should have the right to physician-assisted suicide, or no one should

By Felicia Nimue Ackerman
The Big Idea
Did declining social mobility cause Trump’s rise? In a word, no.Did declining social mobility cause Trump’s rise? In a word, no.
The Big Idea

Contrary to conventional wisdom, places where children out-earn their parents tended to vote for Trump.

By Filipe Campante and David Yanagizawa-Drott
The Big Idea
Progressives should not cave to anemic liberals in the “identity politics” debateProgressives should not cave to anemic liberals in the “identity politics” debate
The Big Idea

To sidestep the goal of equal justice for all betrays a core value of liberalism.

By David Palumbo-Liu
The Big Idea
We missed what was so effective about Donald Trump’s campaign speechesWe missed what was so effective about Donald Trump’s campaign speeches
The Big Idea

Trump had a clear economic message centered on jobs and wages. What was Clinton’s?

By Mike Konczal
The Big Idea
The outrageous legal decision that took overtime pay from millions of workersThe outrageous legal decision that took overtime pay from millions of workers
The Big Idea

A federal judge struck down a Department of Labor standard that’s been uncontroversially used since 1938.

By Jared Bernstein
The Big Idea
Tweedy racists and “ironic” anti-Semites: the alt-right fits a historical patternTweedy racists and “ironic” anti-Semites: the alt-right fits a historical pattern
The Big Idea

Racists have long sought to reposition themselves as modern and sophisticated. The press is perpetually amazed.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
A Wisconsin court case may be the last best hope to fix gerrymandering by 2020A Wisconsin court case may be the last best hope to fix gerrymandering by 2020
The Big Idea

The challenge, on a fast track to the Supreme Court, relies on a new tool to measure the unfair drawing of districts.

By Heather Gerken
The Big Idea
Why America’s roads are so much more dangerous than Europe’sWhy America’s roads are so much more dangerous than Europe’s
The Big Idea

The real story isn’t the recent uptick in deaths. The problem is more fundamental.

By Norman Garrick, Carol Atkinson-Palombo, and Hamed Ahangari
The Big Idea
An American “redemption”? Trumpism fits a pattern of backlash against social progress.An American “redemption”? Trumpism fits a pattern of backlash against social progress.
The Big Idea

There are echoes from the 19th century in the Republican effort to roll back liberal gains.

By Bradley Proctor
The Big Idea
Obama’s best chance to influence the Israeli-Palestinian dispute will come after he leaves officeObama’s best chance to influence the Israeli-Palestinian dispute will come after he leaves office
The Big Idea

Issuing last-minute “parameters” to guide a peace agreement won’t achieve much

By Tony Karon
The Big Idea
Trump’s “populist” economic proposals come with massive catches. Here’s what to watch for.Trump’s “populist” economic proposals come with massive catches. Here’s what to watch for.
The Big Idea

While some of Trump’s economic policy proposals are, in isolation, to be welcomed, many may contain poison pills.

By Wes Yin
The Big Idea
Every president claims to have a mandate. Does Trump actually have one?Every president claims to have a mandate. Does Trump actually have one?
The Big Idea

Mandates are a squishy concept. That doesn’t mean they don’t matter.

By Julia Azari
The Big Idea
For years, I’ve been watching anti-elite fury build in Wisconsin. Then came Trump.For years, I’ve been watching anti-elite fury build in Wisconsin. Then came Trump.
The Big Idea

I did not set out to study rural resentment of “elites,” but that’s what I found.

By Katherine J. Cramer
The Big Idea
Trump is a disaster, but talk of a “whitelash” is misguided — and counterproductiveTrump is a disaster, but talk of a “whitelash” is misguided — and counterproductive
The Big Idea
Trump’s coalition won the demographic battle. It’ll still lose the war.Trump’s coalition won the demographic battle. It’ll still lose the war.
The Big Idea

A great race is on between America’s past and future.

By Ruy Teixeira
The Big Idea
Don’t believe those exit polls saying 25 percent of Latinos voted for TrumpDon’t believe those exit polls saying 25 percent of Latinos voted for Trump
The Big Idea

Clinton drew a record share of the Latino vote, and Latino turnout was huge.

By Gabriel R. Sanchez
The Big Idea
How to coexist, after defeat, with citizens whose views you despiseHow to coexist, after defeat, with citizens whose views you despise
The Big Idea

Democracy means accepting shocking outcomes.

By Melissa Schwartzberg and Jennifer Gandhi
The Big Idea
America’s founders screwed up when they designed the presidency. Donald Trump is exhibit A.America’s founders screwed up when they designed the presidency. Donald Trump is exhibit A.
The Big Idea

The executive branch, observers have long said, contains the seeds of American Caesarism.

By Sanford V. Levinson
The Big Idea
More than 30 percent of voters fail to complete their ballots. Don’t be one of them.More than 30 percent of voters fail to complete their ballots. Don’t be one of them.
The Big Idea

A new service helps you research those often-overlooked local candidates and issues.

By David Axelrod and Mike Murphy
The Big Idea
Offensive political dog whistles: you know them when you hear them. Or do you?Offensive political dog whistles: you know them when you hear them. Or do you?
The Big Idea

Everyone talks about dog-whistling, but the concept is trickier than it first seems.

By Ian Olasov
The Big Idea
Be skeptical when polls show the presidential race swinging wildlyBe skeptical when polls show the presidential race swinging wildly
The Big Idea

Actual voter opinion doesn’t change often during a campaign. But the willingness to respond to polls does.

By Andrew Gelman
The Big Idea
A brief history of the FBI’s meddling in US politicsA brief history of the FBI’s meddling in US politics
The Big Idea

From targeting anti-interventionists in the 1930s to harassing MLK, and beyond.

By Rhodri Jeffreys-Jones
The Big Idea
Are we witnessing the end of the Fox News era?Are we witnessing the end of the Fox News era?
The Big Idea

The network couldn’t control the Tea Party movement it promoted, and faces challenges from more aggressive right-wing outlets.

By Nicole Hemmer
The Big Idea
Some states — including swing states — have flawed voting systemsSome states — including swing states — have flawed voting systems
The Big Idea

Problems include machines that don’t generate a paper trail and a lack of effective auditing.

By Suzanne Mello-Stark
The Big Idea
We might soon have 9 states where pot is simultaneously legal and illegal. That’s a problem.We might soon have 9 states where pot is simultaneously legal and illegal. That’s a problem.
The Big Idea

Marijuana legalization is driving a rethinking of states’ rights.

By Trevor Burrus
The Big Idea
People are tougher on poor, pregnant opioid addicts than well-off onesPeople are tougher on poor, pregnant opioid addicts than well-off ones
The Big Idea

A new study found a way to increase empathy for members of this troubled, growing community.

By Harold Pollack
The Big Idea
Former Justice Department prosecutor: James Comey’s October surprise is “indefensible”Former Justice Department prosecutor: James Comey’s October surprise is “indefensible”
The Big Idea

Yes, Comey was in a tight spot. But there’s a reason the FBI doesn’t comment on investigations — especially before an election.

By Peter Zeidenberg
The Big Idea
When linguistic analysis goes horribly wrong: no, Donald Trump doesn’t “talk like a woman”When linguistic analysis goes horribly wrong: no, Donald Trump doesn’t “talk like a woman”
The Big Idea

The traits one linguist identified can be explained a different way.

By John McWhorter